Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Minnesota starvation experiment

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • The Minnesota starvation experiment




    During World War Two,
    conscientious objectors in the US and the UK were asked to volunteer for medical research. In one project in the US, young men were starved for six months to help experts decide how to treat victims of mass starvation in Europe.

    In 1944, 26-year-old Marshall Sutton was a young idealist who wanted to change the world for the better. As a conscientious objector and Quaker, he refused to fight in the war but he still craved the chance to help his country.

    "I wanted to identify with the suffering in the world at that time," he says. "I wanted to do something for society. I wanted to put myself in a little danger."

    That danger came, unexpectedly, in the shape of a small brochure with a picture of children on the front.

    "Will you starve that they be better fed?" it asked. It was a call for volunteers to act as human guinea pigs in a medical experiment at the University of Minnesota.

    All over Europe people were starving - in the Netherlands, in Greece, in eastern Europe and the Soviet Union - and the US military wanted to learn how best to re-feed them. But first they had to find healthy people willing to be starved.

    Perhaps surprisingly, hundreds of conscientious objectors - or COs - applied, all eager to help. Sutton was grateful to be one of 36 young men chosen.

    "I felt very useful, fulfilled," he says. "There were hundreds of people like me who didn't have that type of opportunity, and I felt very fortunate that I could be there."

    [....]

    But in some ways the project came too late. Even as the experiment continued, one Nazi concentration camp was liberated, then another - and the full horror of starvation became apparent.

    BBC correspondent Edward Ward entered the Buchenwald concentration camp in April 1945, seven days after it was liberated.

    "A hollow-eyed emaciated German Jew hobbled across to me," he reported. The man opened the door of a large cupboard. Inside there were about 20 corpses piled high.

    "'Last night's crop,' said the man, almost casually. 'It'll be the same tomorrow, and the next day, and the next day.' The wretched inmates have been freed from their Nazi tormenters, but they've not yet been freed from slow starvation."

    But while the results may have come too late for many of World War Two's victims, they still could help others.

    In 1946, the researchers released a guide book for aid workers - Men and Hunger.

    Its advice included:
    • Show no partiality, and refrain from arguments; the starving are ready to argue on little provocation, but they usually regret it immediately

    • Informing the group what is being done, and why, is just as important as getting things done - billboards are the easiest way

    • Starvation increases the need for privacy and quiet - noise of all kinds seems to be very bothersome and especially so during mealtimes

    • Energy is a commodity to be hoarded - living and eating quarters should be arranged conveniently

    • A thoughtful worker will make use of the fact that the starving are emotionally affected by the weather -some special and cheerful activities might be saved for bad day

    Pretty interesting. There were so many different things that were done, so many different efforts to just plain help people in WWII, that it seems that we wind up missing a lot of them. We tend to just think of G.I. Joe handing out K-rats to people as their column passed by, but there was so, so much more that went on, in Europe and in Japan.
    It's been ten years since that lonely day I left you
    In the morning rain, smoking gun in hand
    Ten lonely years but how my heart, it still remembers
    Pray for me, momma, I'm a gypsy now

  • #2
    That particular study wasn't just a make-work exercise for COs. It revealed fundamental, predictable changes in both physical and mental health among people who slowly starve to death. It's still cited today among researchers.

    The only way you could get people to volunteer for something like that today is if you made it a narcissistic reality show and promised them a cut of the syndication rights.
    "Alexa, slaughter the fatted calf."

    Comment


    • #3
      I was really surprised to see that there were "volunteers". Different times. Although it reminds me of the Japanese scientists that recently volunteered, knowing the risks, but preferring to put themselves in danger rather than younger men, for whom the medical risks would mean a lifetime of issues.
      Not where I breathe, but where I love, I live...
      Robert Southwell, S.J.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by phillygirl View Post
        I was really surprised to see that there were "volunteers". Different times. Although it reminds me of the Japanese scientists that recently volunteered, knowing the risks, but preferring to put themselves in danger rather than younger men, for whom the medical risks would mean a lifetime of issues.
        There's a slightly similar study going on - the Calerie Study. People volunteer for 2 years to eat 25% fewer calories than optimum. It's interesting and controversial but it's not the kind of sacrifice that the COs did years ago.

        NYT
        "Alexa, slaughter the fatted calf."

        Comment


        • #5
          Originally posted by Gingersnap View Post
          There's a slightly similar study going on - the Calerie Study. People volunteer for 2 years to eat 25% fewer calories than optimum. It's interesting and controversial but it's not the kind of sacrifice that the COs did years ago.

          NYT
          Meh...that's just dieting.
          Not where I breathe, but where I love, I live...
          Robert Southwell, S.J.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by phillygirl View Post
            Meh...that's just dieting.
            Is it really dieting if there's no cheating?
            "Alexa, slaughter the fatted calf."

            Comment

            Working...
            X